Feedback on our St. Francis Pilgrimage Experience

Valarie Milazzo

New Member
Our group of 6 female relatives (ages 18 to 70) completed a self-guided walking pilgrimage from Assisi to Rome on June 14. We walked for 9 days, skipping 3-4 of the stages with most elevation gain due to time limitations. Overall, we found the Way of St. Francis challenging yet rewarding. A highlight was Rieti and the spiritual solace of the Sanctuaries surrounding it. Two of us had walked 160 km of the Camino Frances last April, so we can make comparisons to that experience:
  • The arrival in Rome did not create nearly the same feeling of awe and fulfillment as the arrival in Santiago. Perhaps that was because we found ourselves surrounded by tourists and souvenir hawkers, rather than by other pilgrims who had shared our journey experience.
  • The Way of St. Francis required mental exertion from having to navigate, rather than just follow a well-marked trail. Although we had the Sandy Brown guidebook, 2 maps, gpx tracks, and occasional blue and yellow markers, there was still uncertainty every day. Some of our group found this stimulating, while for others this created a lot of stress.
  • Food was much better Italy. Inexpensive house wine was better in Spain, in my opinion.
  • Some stages ended up being longer than we expected (14-18 miles). Some of us had issues with this, either due to insufficient advance preparation, or not pacing ourselves properly that particular day.
  • We did expect there to be far fewer services available in Italy, so we were more prepared with snacks and water. A positive surprise was the availability of refreshing and pure drinking water fountains in many (sometimes obscure) places along the route.
  • The towns and small cities we stopped at in Italy were fascinating. This made for even more exhausting days, because we could not resist exploring once we arrived at each destination. In Spain, we stayed in the countryside or villages where there wasn't much to see, so we got more rest.


New Member
Hi Valerie, have just chanced upon your post and have cut and pasted your comments into an email to a friend who has just decided to walk from Assisi to Rome next year - hope that you don't mind. Like you, he has previously walked the Camino Frances.

I understand your sentiments regarding the arrival in Rome not being quite the same as one's arrival in Santiago - we had a similar experience when we arrived in St Jean Pied de Port this year having walked from Le Puy en Velay. It was wonderful to be back in St Jean (where we started our Camino Frances in 2016) but not quite the same as being in Santiago. I guess each of such journeys is different and each has to be appreciated for it is rather than isn't.

I think its wonderful that a group that had members as young as 17 and as young as 70 started out together and stayed together - full marks!

best regards,